18:42
Flattening a 9 foot walnut slab with a router sled
Ridgeline Woodshop · 3 hours ago
Asked in the comments: Does the bit gum up if the epoxy is not fully cured?
YouTube comment marketing that earns the click
Commently finds fresh videos in your niche, reads the transcript and the top comments, and drafts one comment that adds something. It posts from your channel at a human pace. Viewers who find it useful tap your name and land on your channel.
Transcript5 of 5 lines used
00:42Before anything, set the sled rails parallel to the slab, not to the bench.
03:15I run a one and a quarter inch surfacing bit, about thirty percent overlap per pass.
07:58If it rocks, flip it and shim the corners with hot glue and wedges.
12:20Thinned epoxy goes into the cracks now, before the final pass.
16:05Last pass, take off a sixteenth at most.
Pick what the comment adds
Bench and Grain
Chapters for anyone coming back to this:
00:42 Rails parallel to the slab
03:15 Bit choice and 30% overlap
07:58 Shimming a rocking slab
12:20 Epoxy before the last pass
16:05 The final sixteenth
From 00:42, 03:15, 07:58, 12:20, 16:05
@benchandgrainShows
Chapters for anyone coming back to this:
00:42 Rails parallel to the slab
03:15 Bit choice and 30% overlap
07:58 Shimming a rocking slab
12:20 Epoxy before the last pass
16:05 The final sixteenth
Bench and Grain
Your channel · slabs, jigs, hand tools
What is YouTube comment marketing?
Getting found by leaving useful comments under other creators’ videos in your niche, from your own channel. It only works one way: the comment has to help the people watching.
Answer
YouTube comment marketing is leaving genuinely useful comments on other creators’ videos in your niche, from your own channel. Viewers read comments while a video plays, and your channel name on a comment is a link. A comment that adds chapters, a missing step or a real question gives them a reason to tap it.
It is discovery, not an algorithm trick. YouTube’s Creator Liaison has said: “Try not to think about the algorithm too much, because the algorithm’s job is to follow the audience.” Comment marketing goes to where the audience already is. YouTube says its Top comments view shows what viewers are “likely to value and interact with”, so a comment that helps rises and a plug sinks. Your handle shows next to every comment you post, and tapping a commenter’s picture opens their profile card with their basic channel info.
The craft is in the comment. Generic praise earns nothing, links get held, and the same text pasted under many videos is exactly what YouTube’s spam policy describes. Our guide on whether commenting helps has the evidence and a checker for your drafts.
How do you do YouTube comment marketing?
Pick your topics, find fresh videos, read before you write, add one useful thing, keep a human pace and check that each comment shows. That is the whole strategy, whether you do it by hand or let Commently do the searching, drafting and pacing.
- 1
Pick topics, not channels to copy
Write down three to five topics per channel that your own viewers search for. Comment only under videos on those topics, so the people who tap your name land on something they wanted.
- 2
Find fresh videos
Search each topic and filter by upload date. A video from the last day or two still has an active comment section; under a month-old video your comment is buried. Channels a little bigger than yours have the readers without the flood.
- 3
Read before you write
Watch the video or skim its transcript, then read the top comments. If someone already made your point, answer a question in the replies instead of posting it again.
- 4
Add exactly one thing
Chapters, a step the video skipped, a short summary, a real question or a specific insight. One of them, written for that video, with no link and no plug.
- 5
Keep a human pace
A few comments a day per channel, spaced across the day, one per video, and a rest before you comment on the same creator again.
- 6
Check that it shows
Open the video signed out. YouTube’s own advice: “If you can’t find your comment in Top comments, sort the comments by “Newest first.”” Missing from Newest first means it was held or removed.
- 7
Make the tap worth it
The comment earns the visit; your channel keeps it. Make sure your newest video matches the topic you commented on.
YouTube comment ideas that earn the tap
Five kinds of comment that add something to a video. Each has a real example from the walkthrough above and a template to copy. Fill the brackets from the video itself.
Chapters
Chapters for anyone coming back to this:
00:00 [first section]
00:00 [second section]
00:00 [third section]
Example Chapters for anyone coming back to this: 00:42 Rails parallel to the slab 03:15 Bit choice and 30% overlap 07:58 Shimming a rocking slab 12:20 Epoxy before the last pass 16:05 The final sixteenth
Best on videos over ten minutes without chapters of their own. People use it to jump around the video.
A missing step
One step worth adding before [mm:ss]: [the step]. It [what it prevents or saves].
Example One step worth adding before 07:58: scribble pencil over the whole face first. Keep surfacing until the last of the pencil is gone, and you know it is flat without guessing from the sled.
Best when you know the topic well enough to spot what was skipped.
A short summary
Short version for anyone in a hurry: [point one], [point two], and [the one thing not to skip at mm:ss].
Example Short version: rails to the slab, not the bench. 1¼ inch bit at about 30% overlap. Epoxy the cracks before the final pass, and keep that pass to a sixteenth.
Best on long, dense tutorials. Busy viewers read it instead of rewatching.
A real question
At [mm:ss], do you [option A] or [option B]? Asking because [your situation].
Example At 12:20, do you wait for the epoxy to fully cure before the final pass, or only until it stops feeling tacky? Wondering if the bit gums up when you go early.
Best when the creator replies to comments. A reply from them lifts your comment.
A specific insight
The [technique] at [mm:ss] also works for [related case]. Same idea: [the principle].
Example The hot glue and wedge trick at 07:58 works for twisted boards on a planer sled too. Same idea: stop the rock first, then let the cutter find flat.
Best when you have tried the thing yourself.
Want to know how a draft reads before you post it? Paste it into the comment checker: it flags links, plugs, repeated text and caps, and shows what is missing.
Is YouTube comment marketing allowed?
Yes, when each comment is a real reply to one video. YouTube’s rules target high-volume, repetitive or deceptive comments, links used to drive traffic, and bought or automated engagement. The table shows where the line sits, and what Commently will never do.
| What you do | What YouTube says | Commently |
|---|---|---|
| One specific comment on a video in your niche | Allowed “We consider engagement to be legitimate when a human user’s primary intent is to authentically interact with the content.” Source | The only kind of comment it drafts. |
| The same “check out my channel” text under many videos | Spam Named as an example: “Posting identical or similar “check out my channel” messages across hundreds of videos.” Source | Every comment is written from one video’s transcript. |
| Many comments in a short time | Spam Posting “large volumes of comments in a short amount of time” may be detected as spam and removed. Source | Daily cap, minimum gap and creator cooldown per channel. |
| Links in comments | Often held “You can hold comments that contain URLs for review.” Sharing links is also on YouTube’s list of spam signals. Source | Never adds links. Your name already links to your channel. |
| Sub for sub offers | Not allowed Listed under fake engagement: “Offering to subscribe to another creator’s channel only if they subscribe to your channel (“sub4sub”)” Source | Never. |
| Bought or bot-made comments | Not allowed “YouTube doesn’t allow anything that artificially increases the number of views, likes, comments, or other metrics either by using automatic systems or serving up videos to unsuspecting viewers.” Source | Posts only from channels you own, at a human pace, and every draft can be reviewed first. |
| Selling or buying fake followers or views (US law) | Banned The FTC’s final rule “prohibits anyone from selling or buying fake indicators of social media influence, such as followers or views generated by a bot or hijacked account.” Source | Sells no engagement of any kind. |
| Posting through YouTube’s API | Allowed, with rules YouTube’s API policies forbid using it to “confuse, deceive, defraud, mislead, misrepresent, defame, abuse, stalk, threaten, spam, surprise, or harass anyone”. Source | Each account is set up with its own YouTube API access and posts one reviewed comment at a time. |
What Commently will not do
Put links in comments
Your name already links to your channel. A link in a comment is the quickest way to get it held.
Comment on the same video twice
One comment per video, per channel. A second match is skipped.
Post in bursts
Caps and minimum gaps hold even on a day with fifty matching videos.
Reuse the same text
Every comment is written for one video, from that video’s transcript and comments.
Buy or fake engagement
No bought likes, views or subscribers and no sub for sub. YouTube’s fake engagement policy bans them, and they are not what this is for.
Keep posting when comments stop showing
When YouTube starts holding a channel’s comments, that channel pauses until you look.
Why do comments reach the right viewers?
Because your audience is already watching other people’s videos. Someone who searches for how to flatten a slab watches a 19 minute video and reads the comments while it plays. That comment section is the most targeted place on YouTube for your channel, and no ad slot reaches it.
24:10
Hand cut dovetails, the slow way that works
Kerf and Square · yesterday
Asked in the comments: Which saw do you use for the pins on hardwood?
14:55
A hex end grain board from offcuts
Hexwood Joinery · 2 days ago
Asked in the comments: How do you keep the hexes from creeping in the clamps?
How does Commently work?
Five plain steps per channel. Commently does the searching and drafting; you decide the pace and can read every comment before it goes out.
- 01
Find fresh videos
Searches YouTube for new videos on each channel’s topics, while the comment section is still being read.
- 02
Read the transcript and top comments
Reads what the creator said and what viewers already asked, so a draft never repeats the top comment.
- 03
Draft one useful comment
Chapters, a missing step, a summary, a real question or a specific insight, written from that video. Review and edit any draft.
- 04
Post on your pace
Posts from the right channel inside its daily cap and minimum gap. Never the same video twice, never back to a creator too soon.
- 05
Track every comment
Likes, replies and whether each comment still shows. A channel pauses itself if YouTube starts holding its comments.
A pace that never looks like a burst
Each channel posts a few comments a day at most, spaced out, never twice on one video and never back to the same creator too soon. Set the limits and the rail shows exactly what a week looks like.
Daily cap per channel
Minimum gap
Creator cooldown
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
Bench and Grainwoodworking · 14 this week
Cooldown on Ridgeline Woodshop, 3 days
3 h 30 m gap
Field Notes Kitchenhome cooking · 9 this week
Quiet Ledgerpersonal finance · 7 this week
Paused after 2 held comments
PostedHeld by YouTubeSkipped: already commented on that videoCreator cooldownPausedChannel paused itself
3 a day
Daily cap per channel
A hard ceiling for each channel, however many matching videos appear that day.
2 h apart
Minimum gap
Comments from one channel are spaced out across the day, never stacked.
1 per video
Never the same video twice
One comment per video per channel. A second match on that video is skipped.
3 days
Cooldown per creator
After commenting on a creator’s video, that channel waits before commenting on them again.
Every comment tracked, and a channel pauses itself
Commently checks each posted comment for likes, replies and whether it still shows to viewers. When YouTube starts holding a channel’s comments, posting from that channel stops until you look.
Posted this week
Flattening a 9 foot walnut slab with a router sledBench and Grain on Ridgeline Woodshop · 2 days ago
14 likes · 3 repliesShows
Weeknight dal, three waysField Notes Kitchen · 2 days ago
6 likes · 1 replyShows
Index funds or target date funds, explained slowlyQuiet Ledger · 3 days ago
never shownHeld
Hand cut dovetails, the slow way that worksBench and Grain on Kerf and Square · 4 days ago
9 likes · 0 repliesShows
Paying off a mortgage early, the actual mathQuiet Ledger · 5 days ago
taken downRemoved
Cast iron care, what actually mattersField Notes Kitchen · 6 days ago
3 likes · 2 repliesShows
Quiet Ledger
Posting paused for Quiet Ledger
Two of its last three comments were held for review and never showed to viewers. Nothing posts from this channel until you review them.
Last 6 comments
Many channels, each with its own topics
One account runs several YouTube channels. Each has its own topics, voice and pace, and comments only on videos that match it.
Bench and Grain@benchandgrain
slab flatteningrouter jigshand toolsfinishing
Voicepractical, shop talkDaily cap3 a dayMinimum gap2 hStatusActive
Field Notes Kitchen@fieldnoteskitchen
weeknight dinnerscast ironlentils and beans
Voicewarm, specificDaily cap2 a dayMinimum gap3 hStatusActive
Quiet Ledger@quietledger
index fundsbudgetingmortgages
Voiceplain, carefulDaily cap2 a dayMinimum gap4 hStatusPaused
Read the guides
Two deep pages for anyone promoting a channel, whether or not you ever use Commently.
Guide with a comment checker
Does commenting on YouTube videos help?
The evidence, YouTube's own rules, and a checker that flags what gets a comment held.
Directory of tactics
Organic YouTube promotion
Every way to promote a channel without ads, rated by effort, time and risk, plus a red-flag check for promotion services.
Questions
Short answers. The guides go deeper.
What is YouTube comment marketing?
Leaving useful comments on other creators’ videos in your niche, from your own channel, so viewers who value the comment tap your name and find your channel. It works when the comment adds something to the video. It fails when the comment is an ad.
Does YouTube comment marketing work?
It works as discovery: your channel name sits under videos your future viewers already watch, and a comment worth reading gives them a reason to tap it. It does not change how YouTube ranks your own videos, and generic praise or plugs earn nothing. The quality of each comment decides it.
Is YouTube comment marketing spam?
Not when each comment is written for one video and adds something. YouTube’s spam policy targets high-volume, repetitive or deceptive comments that drive traffic, plus identical “check out my channel” messages. Commently is built around those lines: no links, no repeated text, no bursts, one comment per video.
How do I keep my comments from being held for review?
Leave out links, hashtags and handles, write in normal case, use one emoji at most and never post the same text twice. YouTube says links, repeated comments and heavy emoji may be detected as spam, and creators can hold comments with URLs. Check a draft with our comment checker.
Does Commently post on its own?
It can, inside the daily cap, minimum gap and cooldowns you set for each channel. You can also review every draft first and post only the ones you approve.
Can one account run more than one channel?
Yes. Each connected channel has its own topics, voice, daily cap and cooldowns, and comments only from itself.
What do I need to start?
A YouTube channel you own and an approved account. Accounts are approved by hand because each one is set up with its own YouTube API access.
Why is there no sign-up button?
Every account is approved and set up by hand. Request early access and we will email you when yours is ready.
Early access
Add yourself to the thread
Accounts are approved by hand, a few at a time. Three fields, no account to create.
CommentlyPinned
Want Commently on your channels? Leave your email, your channel if you like, and how many channels you run. We read every request.
You
Commently